New York Sunday, November 22, 2026

Boldest Voice

Search

Business

Skilled trades leaders say AI cannot replace demand for blue-collar workers

Executives from Ford Philanthropy, Carhartt and Jobs for the Future say AI will change how skilled trades work is done but will not remove the need for human workers, as the industry faces a looming labor shortage and a leaky training pipeline.

© fortune.com

Skilled trades leaders say artificial intelligence will change how plumbers, electricians and auto technicians do their jobs, but they do not expect the technology to replace the people who perform the hands-on work. Speaking at the Fortune 500 Innovation Summit, Mary Culler, president of Ford Philanthropy, said that while nothing is future-proof, many skilled trades roles will still require a human on the job. Her comments came as office workers across the economy rethink how tasks get done under the pressure of AI, and as skilled trades have increasingly been viewed as a more insulated route to a six-figure career.

Culler said auto technicians, who are already in short supply, could increasingly use AI tools to help diagnose vehicle problems. The physical repair work, however, still requires a person. Carhartt chief executive Linda Hubbard made a similar point during an interview with Fortune's Kristin Stoller. She said AI-driven efficiency will change how trades workers operate, but argued that the industry's labor needs will continue to outpace any productivity gains from the technology. Demand is being fueled by the data center boom and broader infrastructure investment, she said, and the country still needs to recruit far more people into the trades to rebuild its infrastructure.

The scale of the demand is significant. Employers are expected to fill roughly 1.7 million skilled trades openings each year through 2034. At the same time, about a quarter of the industry's existing 18 million workers are over 55 and approaching retirement. That combination puts pressure on employers to bring in new workers faster than they are currently doing.

Recruiting those workers has proven difficult. Skilled trades work is not suited to everyone. The jobs can be physically demanding, often take place outdoors in difficult conditions, and can depend on the availability of projects. Yet they also offer relatively strong job security, salaries that can reach six figures, and a path to owning a business, which is increasingly attractive to workers. Maria Flynn, chief executive of Jobs for the Future, said the sector is facing pushback over the cost of college and growing skepticism about which jobs truly require a four-year degree. Decades of trade policies and other economic shifts have also left some communities with fewer skilled trades opportunities than they once had, she said.

Flynn said the industry must rebuild trust and awareness among parents, young people and school counselors, who need a clearer understanding of the 124 different skilled trades occupations and the paths into them. The perception gap is especially visible among the people advising students. According to a report released earlier this year by the Alliance for America's Skilled Trades, 95 percent of counselors agree that trade school is a valuable and credible option after high school. Yet only 54 percent say they often recommend vocational or trade school, and just 28 percent often recommend an apprenticeship. Culler said counselors need to start talking more openly about these opportunities.

Even when students are persuaded, the pipeline remains leaky. The Alliance's September report found that of every 100 people who start an apprenticeship, only 48 complete the program, and just 29 enter a skilled trade occupation within five years of leaving it. Among postsecondary programs, 48 of every 100 entrants complete their training, and only 34 go on to work in a skilled trade. Flynn attributed much of this attrition to a lack of support for workers navigating training, including basic but consequential barriers such as transportation and childcare. She said addressing those gaps will require collective effort across the sector.

49Views

Audrey Baxter

Author

Culture Reporter

Audrey Baxter covers public affairs, politics, business, culture and daily news for Boldest Voice. The role focuses on verification, context, and clear explanations for readers.

Read on