USDA rule changes leave rural businesses and farmers facing lost grants
A Michigan-based grant consultant says USDA's halted REAP applications and new October rule have cost clients millions in rural energy investments and forced layoffs at her firm.
A rural energy grant consultant says a series of USDA decisions has wiped out her business's revenue, forcing her to lay off all five of her employees this year. Sun Grants Consulting, which she founded in 2023 to help farmers and rural small businesses apply for grants through the Rural Energy for America Program, known as REAP, had filed almost 200 applications before the changes took hold. She argues the damage was caused not by competitors or a shrinking market but by the federal government's own decisions.
The trouble began in March, when the U.S. Department of Agriculture announced it would stop processing pending REAP applications and make no further grant awards until new regulations took effect. Applicants who had followed the existing rules would have to start over. Fifty-seven of the consultant's clients were caught in that pause, representing more than $22 million in rural energy investments and more than $9 million in potential grant awards. Because her firm is paid only when clients win grants, its anticipated revenue from those applications disappeared.
A second blow came in October, when USDA issued a new rule that fundamentally changed how future applicants qualify. Under the rule, farmers and businesses generally must complete projects, pay the bills and document 12 months of energy production or savings before they can even apply. The agency itself acknowledges “some uncertainty about whether an applicant will receive an award.” The consultant describes the result as turning an investment incentive into a reimbursement lottery, one that favors the businesses with the most cash on hand to fund projects while they wait for a decision a year or more away.
The effects are concrete for individual applicants. She cites Michigan dairy farmer Ron Rusk, whose application she helped prepare. After applying under the previous rules, Rusk invested approximately $86,000 in solar equipment and sought a grant covering roughly a quarter of the cost. The March reversal left his pending application in limbo, and the October rule ultimately terminated it.
Supporters of REAP say the impact extends well beyond the applicants themselves. The National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition estimates that each REAP grant dollar generates $8.72 in total project spending, supporting work for electricians, installers, manufacturers and rural contractors. USDA's own budget documents describe REAP projects as providing farmers and rural small businesses with “new and sustainable income streams.” Congress created the program in the 2002 farm bill, and it has drawn bipartisan support, including reauthorization in the 2018 farm bill that President Trump signed.
The administration has framed its position in terms of taxpayer spending and market distortion. USDA's March announcement pledged to end “taxpayer handouts” for renewable energy, and a presidential executive order targets “market distorting subsidies.” The department also says REAP grants are taxable income and that a farmer can claim them alongside the federal solar tax credit. Critics counter that the program requires recipients to put their own capital at risk, hire private contractors and pay costs the grants do not cover.
The consultant also points to contrasts in federal policy. In October, USDA announced $8 billion in assistance to farmers facing higher fuel costs. She acknowledges that emergency relief may be warranted, but asks why helping farmers pay for fuel is acceptable while helping them permanently lower their energy bills is condemned. On land use, USDA research found that solar and wind installations directly occupied less than 0.05 percent of U.S. farmland in 2020, a figure she cites to question whether the new restrictions are proportionate to the concern about farmland protection.
A political dimension has also emerged. Brookings found that about two-thirds of REAP grants went to congressional districts now represented by Republicans, and 18 of the 20 districts receiving the most funding are Republican-held. The consultant argues the policies fall hardest on the rural communities the administration says it intends to defend.
She also raises a legal question. Congress directed USDA to “promote” renewable energy and efficiency for rural businesses, yet the new rule itself says the policies behind it direct the agency to “disincentivize solar development on farmland.” In her view, an agency cannot rewrite a statute through policy. Her broader argument is that farmers already manage weather, commodity prices and volatile markets, and should not also have to guess whether Washington will change the rules after they have invested. The views expressed in the commentary are hers alone.
Source: fortune.com
6



