Hourly Workers Face 7.86% Squeeze as Voters Push Back on Data Centers
A Fortune commentary argues that rising everyday costs for hourly workers, combined with labor shortages at warehouses, help explain the local votes against data center expansion across the United States.
Voters in 40 of 41 local contests across 10 states chose to limit data centers on Nov. 3, a result that many observers read as a rejection of the largest industrial buildout in a generation. Simon Khalaf, whose company staffs warehouses near data center sites, argues that the backlash and the buildout are two sides of the same problem: hourly workers are short on pay, and the warehouses that supply the AI boom are short on hourly workers.
Khalaf starts with the paycheck. Headline inflation stood at 3.7% in September, but the Bureau of Labor Statistics itself notes that its index does not necessarily measure an individual's own experience with price change. In a summer survey of 3,083 hourly workers, 69.4% said they earn under $30,000 a year across all their jobs, and only about half have a savings account. To capture what these households actually spend, Khalaf built a weighted measure he calls FeelFlation, weighting each category's cost increase over the 12 months through September by its share of take-home pay.
The result is a 7.86% increase, more than double the headline figure. Rent or mortgage accounts for 28% of take-home pay and rose about 3%. Interest on debt takes 16% and rose roughly 21%, an estimate Khalaf derived from Consumer Financial Protection Bureau data that combines higher rates with balances that stay unpaid longer. Transportation takes 15% and rose 11%, while insurance premiums take 10% and rose 12%. Food, discretionary spending and healthcare account for the rest, with increases of roughly 2.6% to 3%. Khalaf says newer data put insurance premiums up 16%, which would make 7.86% an understatement.
Three categories drive most of the squeeze: interest, insurance and transportation. Together they consume 41% of take-home pay and account for nearly 80% of the increase. Khalaf argues that interest, which adds more than three points on his measure, is a cost the official gauge leaves out because the consumer price index tracks what people buy but not the borrowing used to pay for it. Hourly pay on his company's platform rose 3.1% over the same period, meaning household costs climbed about 4.76 percentage points faster than wages. In the same survey, 67.6% said they pick up an extra shift rather than borrow when an unexpected bill arrives.
On the other end of the equation, Khalaf points to staffing data from warehouses. In Columbus, Ohio, the share of posted warehouse shifts filled on his platform fell from 87.9% in 2024 to 82.8% this year, meaning more than one in six shifts now goes unfilled. Fill rates also declined in every data center metro his company tracks. Northern Virginia dropped from 96.2% to 92.6%, Dallas-Fort Worth from 93.5% to 91.4%, and Phoenix from 91.5% to 90.1%. Across the four metros combined, the rate fell 1.8 points to 90.3%, with Columbus declining nearly three times as much as the group average.
Khalaf acknowledges two caveats. Warehouse shift volume in these metros has more than doubled since 2024, to 17,342 shifts from 7,258, so part of the decline reflects demand outpacing supply. He also cannot trace individual workers from warehouses to data center construction sites. His reading is that the buildout draws the most skilled hourly workers first, leaving warehouses to compete for a shrinking pool. He cites Congressional Budget Office figures showing net immigration fell from about 3.5 million in 2023 to roughly 410,000 in 2025, a decline that further tightens the labor market.
The policy proposals Khalaf offers are aimed at both problems. He argues that Washington should match legal immigration for skilled trades to what the buildout requires. He also proposes a two-to-three-year overtime tax holiday. Under current federal law through 2028, workers can deduct the premium portion of overtime pay, the half in time-and-a-half, from federal taxable income up to $12,500 a year. But that break arrives with the annual tax return, and Social Security and Medicare taxes still apply. Khalaf says moving the benefit into each paycheck would reward the extra shifts workers already take and help fill the shifts warehouses cannot staff.
Finally, Khalaf calls for sharing the financial upside of AI. Labs and data center owners are raising capital on promises of future productivity, and he argues that part of those gains, including equity, should reach the hourly workers who build, supply and staff the facilities. His broader claim is that communities would view data centers differently if they came with higher wages. The opinion piece is one perspective on a debate that voters have now begun to decide at the ballot box.
Source: fortune.com
31



